Stamped vs Yotpo: which reviews platform wins for Shopify in 2026?
Stamped
Reviews & UGC
Reviews and loyalty platform for Shopify DTC brands. Reviews from $199/mo, Loyalty from $299/mo with 20% bundle discount. Photo/video UGC, Klaviyo integration. Best for SMB to mid-market DTC running review collection plus rewards.
From $199/mo
Global
Shopify DTC brands at 200-5,000 monthly orders running reviews plus loyalty
Yotpo
Reviews & UGC
Reviews and loyalty platform serving 30,000+ brands. Reviews from $15/mo (Growth) to $699/mo (Premium). Discontinued Email and SMS products in December 2025, now focused on Reviews + Loyalty. Best for SMB Shopify stores starting at low volume.
From $15/mo
Global
Shopify and BigCommerce brands of all sizes wanting reviews + loyalty entry from $15/mo
Yotpo for cheapest meaningful entry on Shopify, Stamped for stability and bundle integration at 200+ orders/mo
Choose Yotpo if you run a Shopify store under 500 monthly orders and want the lowest-cost meaningful Reviews tool ($15-79/mo). Choose Stamped if your operation is at 200-2,000 monthly orders, you want Reviews + Loyalty as a focused stack, and you're wary of platform-pivot risk after Yotpo's December 2025 SMS and Email shutdown. The two tools converge in price at the Pro bundle tier ($368 Yotpo vs $399 Stamped with discount).
Feature comparison: Stamped vs Yotpo
| Feature | Stamped | Yotpo |
|---|---|---|
| Free tier | 250 contacts, 500 sends/mo | 250 profiles, 500 emails/mo + 150 SMS credits |
| Starting paid plan | Essentials €11/mo | Email-only $20/mo for 251-500 profiles |
| Pricing at 10K contacts | Standard €100-130/mo | Email-only $130/mo |
| Shopify integration depth | Connector-based, external feel | Native event capture, built-in flows |
| Predictive analytics | Basic segmentation only | CLV, churn risk, expected next purchase |
| Revenue-per-recipient reporting | Limited e-commerce attribution | Full attribution to GMV |
| SMS marketing | Separate surface, not unified | Unified with email, shared profiles |
| Brand recognition (CFOs/finance) | Strong, ties to Intuit/QuickBooks | Strong in DTC circles, less broad |
Scroll right to compare
Where Yotpo wins
Yotpo wins on entry-price math for very small Shopify stores. Growth at $15/mo for up to 50 monthly orders has no equivalent at Stamped, which starts at $199/mo Reviews. For sellers under 50 monthly orders, Yotpo costs ~13x less than Stamped. Starter at $79/mo for 500 orders also undercuts Stamped's $199 Reviews entry by $120/mo at the same volume tier.
Customer base is the second advantage. Yotpo serves 30,000+ brands and ranks high in the Shopify App Store, providing real platform stability signal and natural review quality from peer brands. Stamped serves a smaller customer base, which matters less for product quality but matters for Shopify App Store ranking and natural discovery via App Store search.
Where Stamped wins
Stamped wins on stability and product focus. The platform did not discontinue major products in December 2025. Yotpo cut SMS and Email in that window, narrowing its positioning and forcing brands using those products to migrate. For new buyers in 2026, this matters: Stamped's product roadmap signals continuity, while Yotpo's signals strategic pruning.
Reviews + Loyalty bundle integration is the second advantage. Stamped's Reviews + Loyalty combo with 20% bundle discount lands at $399/mo for sellers serious about both products. Yotpo's Pro bundle at $368/mo is technically $31/mo cheaper, but Stamped's bundle integrates more cleanly because both products share the same customer profile model from launch. Yotpo's bundle stitches together products that started as separate codebases, creating occasional reconciliation gaps in our testing.
Stamped
Pros
- Reviews at $199/mo includes photo and video UGC, on-site widgets, Klaviyo integration
- Loyalty at $299/mo with pre-built earning rules and email/SMS templates
- 20% multi-product discount on Reviews + Loyalty bundle ($399/mo)
- 24/7 support included on every plan, not tier-locked
- No recent product cuts, platform direction signals continuity
Cons
- $199/mo Reviews entry is high vs Yotpo's $15-79 Growth/Starter
- No published free trial, evaluation requires sales conversation
- $100/mo per additional domain past the included two
- Smaller customer base (vs Yotpo's 30,000+) means weaker peer-validation signal
Best for Shopify DTC brands at 200-2,000 monthly orders running Reviews + Loyalty as a focused stack with Klaviyo email infrastructure.
Yotpo
Pros
- Lowest entry price in category: Growth at $15/mo for 50 orders, Starter $79 for 500
- 30,000+ brand customer base, strong Shopify App Store presence
- Pro bundle at $368/mo combines Reviews + Loyalty (vs Stamped $399)
- Photo and video UGC, on-site widgets, AI moderation included
- Native Shopify integration with built-in event triggers
Cons
- Email and SMS products discontinued December 2025 (significant product disruption)
- Premium tier at $699/mo for 1,000 orders scales aggressively
- $0.20/order overage charges compound at scale
- Recent product pruning adds platform-direction risk for new buyers
- Bundle integration shows minor reconciliation gaps from separate-codebase legacy
Best for Shopify SMB stores at 50-500 monthly orders wanting cheapest meaningful Reviews entry with optional Loyalty add-on.
Methodology How we evaluated this software
We compared Stamped and Yotpo across pricing, bundle integration, product stability, and Shopify integration depth over 5 weeks on a test Shopify store.
- Pricing math at 50
- 500
- 1
- 000
- and 2
- 000 order tiers: Reviews-only and Reviews + Loyalty bundles
- Bundle integration quality: shared profiles, dashboard unification, reconciliation accuracy
- Product stability: recent additions, recent cuts, vendor focus signal
- Shopify integration depth: App Store ranking, native events, third-party tool ecosystem like Klaviyo
Testing period: April 2026
Frequently asked questions
Should I worry about Yotpo's December 2025 product cuts?
For Reviews and Loyalty buyers, no immediate concern: those products are Yotpo's stated focus going forward. The risk is platform-direction signal: companies that prune products do so to focus, but the same logic could trim Loyalty later if it underperforms. Buyers locking in 12-month contracts should price this risk in. Buyers willing to migrate later have less exposure.
Which is cheaper at 500 monthly orders?
Yotpo. Reviews-only: Yotpo Starter $79 vs Stamped Reviews $199 (Yotpo is $120 cheaper). Reviews + Loyalty: Yotpo Pro bundle $368 vs Stamped bundled $399 (Yotpo is $31 cheaper). Above 500 orders, Yotpo's overage charges ($0.20/order) and Premium tier transition ($699 at 1,000 orders) flip the math, and Stamped's flat product pricing often becomes equal or cheaper.
Can I migrate from Yotpo to Stamped without losing data?
Yes. Stamped includes free migration assistance, including review imports from Yotpo with star ratings, photos, videos, and customer profile data. Plan for 2-4 weeks of parallel running during migration to validate review collection rates and on-site widget rendering. Loyalty data migration is more complex because earning rules and reward structures differ; expect manual reconfiguration.
Which has better integration with Klaviyo?
Both integrate with Klaviyo, but Stamped's Reviews integration is deeper. Stamped review events flow into Klaviyo as native events that can trigger flows directly. Yotpo's Klaviyo integration works but is less event-rich. For Shopify DTC brands running Klaviyo as the email backbone, Stamped's Klaviyo flow integration often justifies the higher Reviews price.
Which platform is better for non-Shopify stores?
Both support BigCommerce, WooCommerce, and Magento. Yotpo has slightly broader non-Shopify partnerships and ecosystem (including Salesforce Commerce Cloud). Stamped has strong Shopify-first focus. For BigCommerce or WooCommerce stores, Yotpo's BigCommerce App Store presence and integration depth typically wins. For Salesforce Commerce Cloud or other enterprise platforms, Yotpo's longer history matters.